Add to My Yahoo! | Google Reader or Homepage | Add to Windows Live | Add to Windows Live Alerts

Wictor Wilén

SharePoint Server MVP / Author / MCT / MCTS / MCP / MSc writing about SharePoint and other interesting Microsoft technologies

Live Mesh, Skydrive and Office Live

Posted at 2008-11-16 01:18 by Wictor Wilén in Microsoft Office , Windows Live with 4 comments.

Microsoft is currently extremely offensive on their new cloud services targeted to consumers and business users with their Live services. I use a number of them daily with the Live Mesh as the newest addition.

A couple of months back I started to move my and my family's documents to Skydrive, 5Gb free online storage, and I’ve made some efforts to get started with the Office Live Workspace, to have a better place work working with the documents. Then Live Mesh came into the picture, and it lets me automatically sync documents between our PC’s and cell phones – really awesome!

All of these three services are really good, but currently none of them is perfect, and the problem is that they do not work together at all. Below is a comparison of some of the features. All three services can be accessed from a standard browser and has features for sharing files and documents with other people.

  Live Mesh Skydrive  Office Live
  Live Mesh Skydrive Office Live Workspace
Storage Space 5Gb 5Gb (25Gb announced) 500Mb
API (i.e. programmable) Yes No No
Synchronization with workstations Yes No No
Calendars No* No* Yes
Custom lists No No Yes
Remote Desktop access Yes No No**
Office integration No*** No Yes (plugin)
Mobile devices support Yes**** No No
Office Live applications integration No Yes***** No
Office file previews No No Yes
Office Live 14 support ****** No No Yes

* You have the feature in other Windows Live applications
** SharedView is used instead
*** If the folder is synchronized with the local PC, then an update to the Office document is synced into the Mesh instantly
**** Currently in a limited closed beta
**** Integration with Office Live Photo Gallery announced
****** Currently not available

As you can see there are several features that do not overlap.

What I would like to see is some kind of merge or collaboration between of these three services.

Imagine having 25Gb online storage of which you can have parts synchronized with different machines and full integration with the Microsoft Office suite (or other Office-like suites for that matter).

I did pop this question to one of the Microsofties at the Live booth at the PDC a few weeks ago, and the reply was that there were no plans of this. I think this is really bad. Yes I understand that they are three different services but I think that the underlying storage should be the same and that some of (if not all) the features above should be available in all three of them. If it would become true, this would truly be a powerful service that no one can neglect to use.

Then just add some subscription to this and let’s say that you can have 100Gb online storage, then I would for sure place all my data and images up there in the cloud.

Do you use any of these services and what do you think?

Comments and trackbacks

#  Online Backup Services by Jade
Screenshot from websnpr For all online backup, file sharing and storage related info, I recommend this website: http://www.BackupReview.info
#  Live Mesh, Skydrive y Office Live: diferencias y semejanzas... by Trackback
Screenshot from websnpr Como sabéis, muchas son las novedades tecnológicas que han aparecido a lo largo del año...el caso es
#  yes! by D One
Screenshot from websnpr i totally agree! i am trying to colaborate making some music from the US to a friend in Spain. we used to use some dinky online storage stuff but i just stumbled upon mesh which is exactly what we're wanted. but then i look at sky drive and say... i want mesh with THAT space. what are they up to anyway? i feel like they're gonna drop the $ signs soon pre sign up though, probably for the extra space. Hope I'm wrong!
#  Extremely Offensive by Todd
Screenshot from websnpr I don't think that you mean what your post says. The way the first sentense is worded, one would think that you are offended by Microsoft's offerings. I think that you mean to say that Microsoft is extremely aggressive or competitive or maybe on the offense, but not offensive.
Make a comment on this post:
Subject:  

Your name:  
Your Url:  
Note: submissions may have to be approved before being visible, so don't submit your comment multiple times.
Real Time Web Analytics